Dear Members of POTHE Music Ministry and Congregation-
A bombshell hit this week with news from experts (medical and singing) warning of the inherent dangers of communal singing in the foreseeable future as a result of COVID-19. So even as we begin to see society “re-open” and eagerly await a return to our church buildings, it is highly likely that what once was will no. longer. be.
From today’s Press Herald: Choirs may have to remain silent long after society reopens
https://www.pressherald.com/?p=5419178
On Thursday Bishop Deeley provided recommendations that we in Maine Parishes are to follow including using only cantors at public masses; avoiding use of our disposable missals during service; singing less and more softly; and wearing masks. At the same time we are encouraged to continue offering livestream Masses as long as we are without a vaccine for COVID-19. Choirs would not be a part of the church re-opening equation at all.
Furthermore, I have read reports that group singing in any form – be it in choirs or congregationally – is risky, even when wearing masks. You most likely have read the stories of places where going to choir rehearsal in March turned deadly. And singing while wearing a mask can cause its own health issues.
https://www.drheathernelson.com/singingandcovid19
We know just how contagious this thing was. And when forced out into the air by robust singing the contagious microscopic aeresols are left behind for hours on end. Although we are hearing that rapid testing may be available in the not-too-distant future, do we take the risk? Do we test everyone before they step foot in the sanctuary? Or do we praise God as we always have and put it all in His hands?
In the words of this music minister: "It will impoverish us not to sing. There's no doubt about it."
Come June 1 we have some tough decisions to implement and deal with head-on, but conversations are beginning amongst my colleagues and my mind is a blur of how to “make it work” in our different locations. We are going to need solutions for the short and long term.
Now is the time to take a deep (at home!) breath and lean heavily on each other to come up with satisfying and safe alternatives.
I welcome your thoughts.
~Jen
pothe@portlanddiocese.org